Where and Why?

On his blog The Dog Ate Daron’s Homework, Diamondbacks broadcaster Daron Sutton announced that in tomorrow’s first spring training game, Conor Jackson would hit clean up.  Earlier in the off-season, there was talk of Eric Byrnes being the cleanup hitter, and indeed that may still be his role, especially against left-handed hitters.  But as long as the subject of lineups has been mentioned, first by Diamondhacks and now by Daron, I might as well weigh-in with my thoughts.

One would have figured at least to start, that if Byrnes wasn’t in the four-hole, Chad Tracy would be there.  After all, he led the team in RBIs and was second to Byrnes in homers.  He struck out a lot last year, but claims that that was because he was not making an adjustment to the pitchers who have adjusted to him.  We did notice that toward the end of the season, Tracy’s strikeout rate did slow down.  So maybe he’s working out the adjustment.  We’ll see a spring training progresses.  Again, he is likely to see some time there — spring training lineups are quite fluid — but manager Bob Melvin has indicated that he would like to bat Tracy third.

Conor Jackson is an interesting selection.  Jackson has the patience at the plate but not the speed on the base paths that would make him a good table setter.  He and Byrnes tied for second in RBIs among the Diamondbacks last year.  And they were both just one behind Chad Tracy in a race that was not decided until the ninth inning of the final game.  He likes the pressure of the cleanup spot, something that the numbers suggest Byrnes is not all that comfortable with.  Jackson also understands that a double with runners in scoring position will be fine; one does not always need a homer.  There is some concern at that Tracy who, after 2005, was expected to be the team’s homer leader, might try too hard for the four-bagger if he’s hitting cleanup. 

If it turns out that Conor Jackson is the man for the cleanup role, where should the Diamondbacks slot Eric Byrnes and why?  I think, for early spring training at least, he should hit second.  His lifetime stats show that he has his highest batting average in the second spot.  But that would be just to get him going.  In about two weeks, I’d start giving him at-bats in the fifth position.  And I’d tell him now, if he hasn’t been told already, that the five-hole is really where he should be.

Rather than thinking of the lineup as having three parts, I like to think of it as having two: 1 — 4, and 5 — 8, with the pitcher who can slap a single or at least bunt, or a pinch-hitter, linking the two halves during a rally.  That makes the five-hole a transition spot for which Byrnes’ combination of talents is well suited.  He has the pop in his bat that can drive in a runner ahead of him and the speed afoot that can make him a table-setter for the second half of the order.  This is especially useful for a team like the Diamondbacks, who have a fairly even lineup.



  1. Kellia

    No, because I advocate a different approach for Byrnes, one that I think hasn’t been tried in his career yet: an approach to his psychology as a hitter, with the goal of giving him an identity as a hitter. And the focus on what he does right.

    I would make him examine what he does in May, which is historically his best month. He’s a lifetime .300+ hitter in May no matter who’s pitching. A month is a long enough time to show that he could hit righthanders better throughout the season, if only he understood what he does right in May. I would make him look at the videos of what he does right in May. I would make him think about everything he does in May to try to pinpoint the differences between that month and the others. I’d tell him to articulate what is different about May. Then I tell him that based on what he has done in Mays past, and based on his own proclivities as a hitter — at Fan Fest, he said he likes to swing at the ball and make it go as far as it will go — he needs to be a 5-hitter. (Even there, he needs a bit more flexible approach. I hope Kevin Seitzer is talking to him about things like opposite-field and contact hitting). But he needs a place. He’s never really had that.

    Making him to switch positions in the lineup based on who is pitching, only reinforces in his mind the differential. It builds an approach to playing him that focuses on a weakness, rather than focusing on a strength. Sitting him a third of the year is that same approach. I want him thinking about what he does right so that he’ll do more of it, not thinking about where he has difficulty because then he’ll do more of that.

    Now there may be a pitcher, like Derek Lowe, where you might want to bat him fourth. Or there may be a pitcher that has his number so bad you might want to give him a day off. But both these occurrences should be rare.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s