Stats — The Ups & Downs of Eric Byrnes

This is the second part of a long article, segmented for online reading convenience, on Eric Byrnes’ batting difficulties, and the mental aspect of solving these problems. WARNING: If you don’t like Eric Byrnes, now is definitely the time to leave. In fact, if you don’t like Eric Byrnes, you’ve wandered into the wrong blog.

Here are some stats with which to lay the foundation for my theses. They will be especially helpful to you Eric Byrnes novices:

Eric Byrnes made his major league debut on August 22, 2000, with the Oakland A’s. He made the A’s Opening Day roster in 2003. Here are some stats for 2003-2005 from

          G AB  Avg  HR  RBI  H    R

2003 121 414 .263 12   51  109 64

2004 143 569 .283 20   73  161 91

2005 126 412 .226 10   40   93   49

In 2005, Byrnes played 59 games with Oakland, 15 with Colorado and 52 with Baltimore. (He actually batted in only 47 of the 52 Orioles games).

As I have said repeatedly in other posts, 2005 was Byrnes’ "abysmal, aberrant year." It is not unusual for professional athletes to have a season that they would love to just excise from the record books. Typically, it’s the dreaded "sophomore jinx" or it’s a year near the end of the career that signals a diminution of skills brought on by the cumulative effects of age and injuries sustained over the course of the career. Sometimes, it’s a year ruined by a major injury requiring significant DL time and possibnly surgery. Byrnes’ second year was the best of the three full seasons he’s had in the majors so far. He doesn’t turn 30 until February 16, 2006. One look at him will tell you that he is in great shape.

In fact, here’s the photo of him, taken by Daryl of Daryl’s Place, that I keep as wallpaper on my home computer. Byrnes1

Fortunately, Byrnes has not ended up on the DL from all the banging into walls and diving on the ground he’s done to make all the spectacular catches he’s made to rob opponents of extra-base hits.

He has also managed to escape serious injury from the rather painful-looking positions in which he’s ended up while batting. For example, another of Daryl’s great digital catches at Camden Yards: Ebankles

(Holy ankle-sprains, Batman!)   

Here’s the big problem: Eric Byrnes is a model of inconsistency.

All batters have hot spells and slumps, but Byrnesie, as we call him in the S.F. Bay Area, has always been notoriously streaky. Here are some descriptions from his official MLB web page for 2003:

…replaced [Jermaine] Dye in the fifth inning on April 24 against Detroit after [Dye] tore cartilage in his right knee fielding a Dean Palmer double…had his first multiple hit game of the season that day and moved into the starting line-up on April 25…had seven consecutive games with an extra base hit from May 8 to 15 (four doubles, three triples, one homer)…that began a career-high 22 game hitting streak from May 8 to June 1, during which he hit .376 (32 for 85) with 10 doubles, three triples, four home runs and 20 RBI… went 0 for 9 in his next two games before putting together a 10-game hitting streak from June 5 to 15 (15 for 40, .375)…had the hitting streak snapped on June 17 and then put together a 13-game hitting streak from June 18 to 30 (21 for 59, .356)…had a career high four RBI on May 15 at Detroit…homered in all three games of the Montreal series, June 13-15, the first time he had homered in three straight games in his career…tied an Oakland record with a career high five hits on June 29 at San Francisco when he hit for the cycle… at the end of June, he had hit safely in 23 of his last 24 games and 45 of his last 48 and was batting .335 overall…that was the fifth best average in the A.L., his highest ranking of the season…then hit .095 (7 for 74) in 20 games in July…snapped a career long 0 for 17 slump on July 20…appeared in just 12 of the A’s 28 game from July 22 to August 20 before ending his 9 for 95 slump with a two-hit game at Boston on August 21…the slump had dropped his average 66 points to .270 but he went 7 for 17 (.412) over a nine-game stretch from August 21 to September 8…replaced the injured Chris Singleton in center field on September 9 and started 16 of the A’s final 18 games (8 for 49, .163)…snapped a 39-game, 121-at bat homerless streak on September 11 against Anaheim.

Of course, pitchers have a say in these matters. Have a series against a team with a stellar pitching staff and you can be 0-17 in a hurry. But 2005 included longer dry spells, such as a very depressing 0-37 streak broken by a double off Boomer Wells in the last week of the season. After hitting safely in his first 11 games as an Oriole, Byrnes struggled at the plate for the rest of the season at an unprecedented level, even given his characteristic streakiness. The Orioles announcers were hoping Byrnes could get a broken bat single to get him started. But his broken bat contacts ended up being outs, like this one Daryl got the last Sunday the A’s played in Baltimore:


Broken bat AND treacherous ankle positions! <shudder> Sometimes, if you don’t have bad luck, you wouldn’t have any luck at all.

Kéllia Ramares
Oakland, CA



    eric byrnes is a really cool guy! do you like the orioles or just byrnes? id like to see him in boston, personally

  2. Kellia

    Yes, Eric Byrnes is really cool and I only took interest in the Orioles when they got him. As long as they keep him, I hope they do well. If they let him go, I will go back to not caring one way or the other about them. I found when Byrnesie got exiled to the cellar of the NL Worst that rooting for him meant rooting for the whole team. But once he left the Rockies, I forgot about them again.

    I don’t think Eric will wind up in Boston. If the BoSox trade Manny, they will need a new LF, but they will want someone with more proven ability to be protection for David Ortiz. Much as I love Byrnes, he’s not the one. Not yet, anyway.

    Thanks for writing and please come back anytime. Always happy to hear from other Byrnes fans.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s